Didn't Have To Say Goodbye

Didn't Have To Say Goodbye
Created by: johnny_luddite
Tracks: 16
Length: 01:08:05
Keywords 1. suicide
2. lost
3. waste
Created on 5/7/07 11:52pm
Level 6
Points 2548
Total visitors 62
Unique visitors 32
description:
A couple of incidents involving people I cared about in the last year got me to thinking about some of the musicians who took their own lives. I'm glad that they were able to share their music for a while at least, and mourn that they felt their lives had to end. This ones for the ones for whom the music wasn't enough...

tracklist

1 Joy Division : Atmosphere
I saw Joy Division a couple of times. Ian Curtis looked so frail, so human on stage, as if you could just scoop him up and crush him with your hand. His voice seemed to be unconnected to the fading person on the stage somehow.
SHOW MORE
Track 1 from Substance
Length: 00:04:11
Track Description:
I saw Joy Division a couple of times. Ian Curtis looked so frail, so human on stage, as if you could just scoop him up and crush him with your hand. His voice seemed to be unconnected to the fading person on the stage somehow.
SHOW LESS
2 The Tornados : Telstar
This kind of works well after Joy Divison, but I have no idea why. This was a 'beat' instrumental with odd little sci-fi blips and noises that was a big hit on both sides of the Atlantic in the very early pre Beatles sixties. The figure that interests us for the purposes of this mix is not a band member but the producer, Joe Meek. He recorded bands in his studio, a small apartment above a shop in the Holloway Road, North London. The echo chamber was his bathroom, if they had a string section, they had to perch on the stairs. Meek was one of the first producers to really 'produce' playing about with the sounds that were available, constructing his own amps, phasers, etc. Quite a few British hits were recorded in his tiny place. If you get a chance, try and listen to a compilation of his productions. There are a few about. The songs are mostly trashy, but it is fascinating trash. Anyway, he is in this mix because in 1967 he shot his landlady and then turned the gun on himself. Awful tragic stuff, which in a weird way has only seemed to enhance his legend.
SHOW MORE
Track 2 from Telstar:The Original Sixties Hits
Length: 00:03:17
Track Description:
This kind of works well after Joy Divison, but I have no idea why. This was a 'beat' instrumental with odd little sci-fi blips and noises that was a big hit on both sides of the Atlantic in the very early pre Beatles sixties. The figure that interests us for the purposes of this mix is not a band member but the producer, Joe Meek. He recorded bands in his studio, a small apartment above a shop in the Holloway Road, North London. The echo chamber was his bathroom, if they had a string section, they had to perch on the stairs. Meek was one of the first producers to really 'produce' playing about with the sounds that were available, constructing his own amps, phasers, etc. Quite a few British hits were recorded in his tiny place. If you get a chance, try and listen to a compilation of his productions. There are a few about. The songs are mostly trashy, but it is fascinating trash. Anyway, he is in this mix because in 1967 he shot his landlady and then turned the gun on himself. Awful tragic stuff, which in a weird way has only seemed to enhance his legend.
SHOW LESS
3 Nirvana : Heart-Shaped Box
Just when I have always been ready to give up on rock as a force to shake things up, a band has always come along to prove me wrong. Nirvana were not the greatest band to ever abuse a sound system on stage, but there was something about Cobain that was compulsive. This has one of my favorite non-guitar solos of all time.
SHOW MORE
Track 3 from In Utero
Length: 00:04:41
Year: 1993
Track Description:
Just when I have always been ready to give up on rock as a force to shake things up, a band has always come along to prove me wrong. Nirvana were not the greatest band to ever abuse a sound system on stage, but there was something about Cobain that was compulsive. This has one of my favorite non-guitar solos of all time.
SHOW LESS
4 Elliott Smith : Twilight
I see something of the fragile beauty of John Frusciante's work in that of Elliott Smith. There is something really heartbreaking about the way this is performed.
SHOW MORE
Track 4 from From A Basement On The Hill
Length: 00:04:30
Year: 2004
Track Description:
I see something of the fragile beauty of John Frusciante's work in that of Elliott Smith. There is something really heartbreaking about the way this is performed.
SHOW LESS
5 Del Shannon : Runaway
Anyway you boil it, this is a great pop song. One of those songs where every element works in the context of the number.
SHOW MORE
Track 5 from Runaway
Length: 00:02:21
Track Description:
Anyway you boil it, this is a great pop song. One of those songs where every element works in the context of the number.
SHOW LESS
6 Johnny Ace : You've Been Gone So Long
Some lovely and very rare jump blues from the late great Johnny Ace. One of the stranger deaths in a catalog of strangeness, his demise went like this. He had been a B.B.King sideman, but left to go solo and went on tour. During a break he apparently got into a drunken game of Russian Roulette. He fired his gun at his girlfriend and then her friend. Both chambers were blank. Then he turned the gun on himself. You can guess the rest. Rumours that was really a murder have surfaced from time to time.
SHOW MORE
Track 6 from The Complete Kent recordings
Length: 00:02:35
Track Description:
Some lovely and very rare jump blues from the late great Johnny Ace. One of the stranger deaths in a catalog of strangeness, his demise went like this. He had been a B.B.King sideman, but left to go solo and went on tour. During a break he apparently got into a drunken game of Russian Roulette. He fired his gun at his girlfriend and then her friend. Both chambers were blank. Then he turned the gun on himself. You can guess the rest. Rumours that was really a murder have surfaced from time to time.
SHOW LESS
7 The Band : tears of rage
Richard Manuel, keyboard player with the Band throughout the years that mattered, co-wrote this song with Bob Dylan for the first Band album. His role in The Band diminsihed as the years went by and his problems got worse, but when this was recorded he was as vital to them as Robbie Robertson.
SHOW MORE
Track 7 from music from the big pink
Length: 00:05:23
Year: 1968
Track Description:
Richard Manuel, keyboard player with the Band throughout the years that mattered, co-wrote this song with Bob Dylan for the first Band album. His role in The Band diminsihed as the years went by and his problems got worse, but when this was recorded he was as vital to them as Robbie Robertson.
SHOW LESS
8 Badfinger : Day After Day
When Badfinger front person Pete Ham hung himself, he was the second band member to committ suicide. Ham left a mention in his suicide note saying that the bands manager was a crook. This song is very McCartneyish (McCartney wrote some songs for the band, who recorded for Apple) but there is something about it I always liked.
SHOW MORE
Track 8 from The Very Best Of Badfinger
Length: 00:03:11
Track Description:
When Badfinger front person Pete Ham hung himself, he was the second band member to committ suicide. Ham left a mention in his suicide note saying that the bands manager was a crook. This song is very McCartneyish (McCartney wrote some songs for the band, who recorded for Apple) but there is something about it I always liked.
SHOW LESS
9 Hope of the States : Nehemiah
Hope Of The States were just beginning to grab a bit of attention in the months before I was going to leave the UK. They had almost finished their first album (which this comes from) when guitarist James Lawrence topped himself. The album came out later in the year and it sounded good to me, in an era when not much was.
SHOW MORE
Track 9 from The Lost Riots
Length: 00:04:09
Year: 2004
Track Description:
Hope Of The States were just beginning to grab a bit of attention in the months before I was going to leave the UK. They had almost finished their first album (which this comes from) when guitarist James Lawrence topped himself. The album came out later in the year and it sounded good to me, in an era when not much was.
SHOW LESS
10 Feeder : Swim
Feeder sounded a bit like Wonderwall era Oasis on this but I like it anyway. Drummer Jon Lee didn't find the one to save him sad to say.
SHOW MORE
Track 10 from Swim
Length: 00:03:20
Track Description:
Feeder sounded a bit like Wonderwall era Oasis on this but I like it anyway. Drummer Jon Lee didn't find the one to save him sad to say.
SHOW LESS
11 Nick Drake : Black Eyed Dog
I have used this track in a mix before, but it is like no other Nick Drake track as far as I am concerned. His friends and family maintain that his death from an overdose of prescription anti-depressants was an accident, not deliberate, but the coroner ruled it a suicide. I was one of the few thousand who listened to his music in his lifetime. He only ever did 12 live dates, and sold less than 4,000 records in his lifetime. I discovered him through an Island label sampler called "Nice Enough To Eat" and the song 'Time Has Told Me'. I still play his stuff today.
SHOW MORE
Track 11 from Way to Blue
Length: 00:03:26
Track Description:
I have used this track in a mix before, but it is like no other Nick Drake track as far as I am concerned. His friends and family maintain that his death from an overdose of prescription anti-depressants was an accident, not deliberate, but the coroner ruled it a suicide. I was one of the few thousand who listened to his music in his lifetime. He only ever did 12 live dates, and sold less than 4,000 records in his lifetime. I discovered him through an Island label sampler called "Nice Enough To Eat" and the song 'Time Has Told Me'. I still play his stuff today.
SHOW LESS
12 Chicago : I'm a Man
Another Russian roulette player, Mr Kath's last words on this planet are said to have been "Don't worry, it's not loaded" which is a bit like the Civil War General who said "Don't worry men, they could never hit us from that distance" shortly before being hit from that distance. I liked the rocky noisy Chicago.
SHOW MORE
Track 12 from Chicago Transit Authority
Length: 00:07:43
Year: 1969
Track Description:
Another Russian roulette player, Mr Kath's last words on this planet are said to have been "Don't worry, it's not loaded" which is a bit like the Civil War General who said "Don't worry men, they could never hit us from that distance" shortly before being hit from that distance. I liked the rocky noisy Chicago.
SHOW LESS
13 Roy Buchanan : WHen A Guitar Plays The Blues
One of the first and finest of the white blues guitar players. I keep finding new things in his playing and his work means more to me than those of some very very big names in the field. Some of his later live stuff is astonishing!
SHOW MORE
Track 13 from Deluxe Edition
Length: 00:06:37
Track Description:
One of the first and finest of the white blues guitar players. I keep finding new things in his playing and his work means more to me than those of some very very big names in the field. Some of his later live stuff is astonishing!
SHOW LESS
14 Canned Heat : Bullfrog Blues
Another one close to my heart. Not many white blues bands ever did 'get it'. Canned Heat are one that did, and they were never the same after Al "Blind Owl' Wilson took his own life.
SHOW MORE
Track 14 from Lets Work Together
Length: 00:02:17
Track Description:
Another one close to my heart. Not many white blues bands ever did 'get it'. Canned Heat are one that did, and they were never the same after Al "Blind Owl' Wilson took his own life.
SHOW LESS
15 Donny Hathaway : The Ghetto
A fine creative soul singer. This was one of the best songs from his best period, when he recorded for Atlantic. He jumped from the fifteenth floor of a hotel.
SHOW MORE
Track 15 from Everything Is Everything
Length: 00:06:53
Track Description:
A fine creative soul singer. This was one of the best songs from his best period, when he recorded for Atlantic. He jumped from the fifteenth floor of a hotel.
SHOW LESS
16 The Temptations : Cloud Nine
Oh God this is good. If this mix achieved anything, it was to get me to hear this for the first time in a million years or so. Paul Williams was the Temptation who was tempted too much. Hell's teeth, I have to play this again!
SHOW MORE
Track 16 from Cloud Nine
Length: 00:03:31
Track Description:
Oh God this is good. If this mix achieved anything, it was to get me to hear this for the first time in a million years or so. Paul Williams was the Temptation who was tempted too much. Hell's teeth, I have to play this again!
SHOW LESS

Tag Board

The Yay! Badge VII badge
The Yay! Badge VII
Level 27
"Black Eyed Dog" was lightning in a bottle.
10/9/08 8:23am
The Level 15 Badge badge
The Level 15 Badge
Level 16
Don't think I've heard at least 1/2 of these, but what I do know I like very much (that Badfinger tune as an example).
9/19/08 12:29pm
The Bronze Badge badge
The Bronze Badge
Level 13
The musician from Lush
11/22/07 1:11am
Bea
The Lotto Badge badge
The Lotto Badge
Level 21
Why do I only know 6 of these songs? Why.... I feel hopeless/lost/stupid

You are so much about the music - your descriptions kick a donkey's ass!
5/17/07 8:08am
The Valentine's Day 2008 Badge badge
The Valentine's Day 2008 Badge
Level 19
Telstar! I love that song, I have the 7".
5/11/07 8:48am
The Bronze Badge badge
The Bronze Badge
Level 24
Very melancholy, the songs are amazing, I like the artwork, as usual, +++++.
5/8/07 4:12pm
The Yay! Badge XII badge
The Yay! Badge XII
Level 22
nice mix yet again. my heart hurts
5/8/07 8:42am
The MTC Romance Badge badge
The MTC Romance Badge
Level 18
very fine picks, cover art
5/8/07 12:45am